A Social Democracy works just fine..there is no Gestapo on street corners....
I'll ask you this question....
you've been to Canada...
What freedoms don't they have, that Americans have?
Are Canadians suppressed? Are they slaves? do they not buy and do what they want? Are they not just people working and playing and raising their kids? Nobody stands over them and tells them what to do....they have the same choices Americans have...Ask JuJu what it is like..
The Canadian Federal budget was in a surplus till this recession...with all the same programs as the US has...how do you explain that one away?
I hate to say it, but Canada is "out-republicing" the US. They are fiscally stronger than us. They are becoming socially conservative; whereas, we are becoming more liberal. Yet, where they do spend socially, the money is accounted for. They are becoming industrially stronger than us, per capita. They don't tolerate illegal immigration. Canada spends less per student, yet yields a higher return upon graduation.
Yes, Canada's taxes are too high; but the US is catching up (or have passed Canada). The US still has the best medical system in the world, but is quickly headed for the gutter if costs cannot be reigned in, due to the non-payers. And, Canada would never have that surplus if they spent the same percentage of GDP that the US does on defense and foreign spending.
But overall, I agree with your assumption. It's not so much that Canada is on par with the US; it's that the US is sinking below Canada's level. We have 10 times as many people as Canada, while we have many more on the welfare rolls - including 15 million illegal aliens. So, saying Canada is a social democracy, while the US is not, is crazy. I'm thinking Canada has learned a lot from their "socialist-lite" history, and is learning that it doesn't work well. France is another country doing so.
Conservatism may not be en-vogue, but it's becoming apparent to many around the world that it is the prudent ideology. Canada's predicament isn't that bad because they learned this BEFORE the recession hit; while the US is learning this the hard way... after the fact... one state, or one federal bureaucracy at a time.