Pat Buchanan has counted up the Jews on the Supreme Court

Turtle

Administrator
Staff member
Retired Expediter
Buchanan or the idiot who wrote the Blog and erroneously stated, that Buchanan stated, that there are too many Jews on the Supreme Court?

There are too many people on the court from the east coast, that's for dаmn sure. East Coasters think they know best, and are the most out of touch with the rest of us.
 

layoutshooter

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
Buchanan or the idiot who wrote the Blog and erroneously stated, that Buchanan stated, that there are too many Jews on the Supreme Court?

There are too many people on the court from the east coast, that's for dаmn sure. East Coasters think they know best, and are the most out of touch with the rest of us.

So are many of those on the West Coast, Chicago, Detroit and several similar places.
 

Rabbit

Expert Expediter
So... How does this relate to Bucahanan's life-long devotion to and praise of Barry Goldwater, who was a Jew?
 

Rabbit

Expert Expediter
Does it matter?

There's a wide perception that Mr. Buchanan is an anti-Semite, due to his anti-Israel foreign policy positions and a book on WWII he recently wrote in which he in essence claimed (wrongly, IMO) that Hitler wasn't entirely to blame for the war in Europe. Even though I don't agree with Mr. Buchanan on _many_ issues, I'm tired of him being labeled as something that I think he's not by his detractors, specifically those of the stripe that find anyone and everyone who doesn't agree with them to be some flavor of "evil" or another.

Therefore, I'm offering his support of and belief in Mr. Goldwater as a counterweight to what I see as a rather nasty and unwarranted assault on Buchanan's character.
 

layoutshooter

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
There's a wide perception that Mr. Buchanan is an anti-Semite, due to his anti-Israel foreign policy positions and a book on WWII he recently wrote in which he in essence claimed (wrongly, IMO) that Hitler wasn't entirely to blame for the war in Europe. Even though I don't agree with Mr. Buchanan on _many_ issues, I'm tired of him being labeled as something that I think he's not by his detractors, specifically those of the stripe that find anyone and everyone who doesn't agree with them to be some flavor of "evil" or another.

Therefore, I'm offering his support of and belief in Mr. Goldwater as a counterweight to what I see as a rather nasty and unwarranted assault on Buchanan's character.

OK, I see what your getting at.

I don't agree, however, with your statement that Buchanan's claim that Hitler was not entirely to blame for WWII was incorrect. I believe that was a very correct statement.

Excluding the extreme long term causes for the war you must put a lot of the blame on England and France for their extremely harsh treatment of Germany at the end of WWI. Had that treaty been a more "forgiving" treaty, for lack of a better term, then the conditions that allowed for Hitler to rise in power might not have taken place.

I am of the opinion that the lessons learned from that round in history led to the Marshall Plan after WWII. That plan was one of the reasons why we have not yet had a 3rd war of the WWII magnitude in Europe.
 

greg334

Veteran Expediter
I also feel Hitler was not the main cause of the war, he started the actual fighting but the war started with the capitulation of Germany in 1918 (the allies won by default) but more importantly the signing of Treaty of Versailles in 1919. France was still stinging by their losses in 1871. They wanted blood and they gutted Germany and forced them into a situation where they could not get out of unless there was a war.

As far as Buchanan, I feel he has a lot of anti-Israel in him and more a bit left than he appears to be.
 
Top