Loonie's rise signals end of American era

OntarioVanMan

Retired Expediter
Owner/Operator
The story of the soaring Canadian dollar is no longer just about shopping in Buffalo or the troubles faced by domestic exporters. It is no longer just about Canada at all.

Rather, the story of the soaring Canadian dollar is now about something far more dramatic and dangerous. It is about the decline of the American dollar as the world's currency of choice. It is about the end of a world financial system that has been in place, in one form or another, since the 1930s and that has given the developed world unprecedented wealth. It is about America's economic chickens coming home to roost. It is about the end of empire.

And for Canada, which has prospered from its privileged position near the heart of this empire, it is potentially very bad news.

At the heart of the problem is a development that Canadians have difficulty getting used to: The American dollar, which we tend to see as a fixed star in the firmament of currencies, is falling. It is falling relative to every major currency – the euro, the Japanese yen, the British pound. It is falling relative to gold. It is falling relative to oil.

The fact that a barrel of oil now costs about 40 per cent more than it did in August is tied in large part to the depreciation of the currency in which its value is measured: The U.S. dollar.

Every successful empire brings with it an imperial currency. In Roman times, the denarius dominated trade in what is now Europe. At the height of the British Empire, the pound sterling was literally as good as gold.

Similarly, when empires wane, so do their currencies. As Rome overextended itself with military adventures, it devalued the denarius. In 1931, depression-torn Britain officially served notice that its empire was on the rocks when it decoupled the pound from gold.

Since then, the U.S. dollar has been the world's currency of choice. Arab princelings demanded dollars for their oil. So did Colombian cocaine dealers.

When China abandoned Maoism, it was dollars that Communist authorities wanted in exchange for the exports they sent abroad.

So it was perhaps appropriate, yesterday, that it fell to Chinese central banker Xu Jian to announce officially what economists have been saying for years: the dollar is "losing its status as a world currency." China, he explained, would no longer keep just American dollars in its reserves but would diversify its holdings to include other major currencies.

Given that China's central bank holds $1.43 trillion worth of U.S. dollars, that was not an insignificant statement.

The reasons for the dollar's decline are familiar. Like the Romans and British before them, the Americans have overextended themselves. As a country, they import more than they export. As individuals, they spend more than they earn.

Up to now, these excesses have been balanced by the rest of the world's willingness to hold dollars. China, for instance, was willing to take dollars in exchange for useful manufactured goods because it believed the U.S. currency would hold its value.

In a sense, it was like a giant pyramid scheme. As long as everyone believed the dollar was strong, it remained strong.

But as soon as a crack appeared, the edifice shuddered.

If the American dollar were just America's dollar, none of this might matter. Indeed, a lower U.S. dollar, by boosting American exports, will help the U.S. get through any downturn sparked by that country's housing and mortgage crises.

But the U.S. dollar is not just America's. It is the world's currency; it provides a platform of stability on which other countries can operate.

French president Nicolas Sarkozy sounded the alarm yesterday in his address to the U.S. Congress. For America to stand by and let its dollar collapse, he said, is to risk a trade war of global dimensions.

What he meant was that Europe would not let the U.S. engage in competitive devaluation without retaliating.

And this is the danger for Canada. As a small trading nation, Canada is sure to be sideswiped in an all-out trade war. As a small trading nation, Canada also depends on a stable international financial system based on a stable international currency.

So forget the minor ups and downs of the loonie. Sure, it matters if the Canadian dollar sits at $1.08 (U.S.) or $0.88. But it matters more if the U.S. dollar itself is under stress. The key development yesterday was not the fact that Canada's dollar closed down slightly from the day before. It was the fact that, relative to the euro, the U.S. dollar hit a record low.
 

copdsux

Veteran Expediter
Charter Member
Ken: You forgot to credit the author of this copyrighted story.
Thomas Walkon, National Affairs columnist, Toronto Star.
 

greg334

Veteran Expediter
OK I read this and a bunch of other articles similar to it in the last week. But there are a couple things I find disturbing or wrong.

“When China abandoned Maoism, it was dollars that Communist authorities wanted in exchange for the exports they sent abroad.â€

China did not abandoned Maoism in any way shape of form and it has used the dollar, just as the soviets used it for trade since the 50’s. The author, like many others seem to gloss over the hard fact that China has not changed it political philosophy.

“So it was perhaps appropriate, yesterday, that it fell to Chinese central banker Xu Jian to announce officially what economists have been saying for years: the dollar is "losing its status as a world currency." China, he explained, would no longer keep just American dollars in its reserves but would diversify its holdings to include other major currencies.â€

China has always had a diverse portfolio with their currency holdings; they hold the debt to a lot of countries not just the US. The statements that have been published have been rather to show they are willing to go somewhere else and to scare us into some action. The thing is when the dollar fell, it opened up out markets for property and companies for them to purchase. They haven’t been dumping dollars like everyone expected but rather Dubai and a few other Middle Eastern countries have been quick to take advantage.

“The reasons for the dollar's decline are familiar. Like the Romans and British before them, the Americans have overextended themselves. As a country, they import more than they export. As individuals, they spend more than they earn.â€

This is so d*mn true it is not funny, the American people are so ignorant and stupid that they don’t think about the dollar but how to get the next iPhone or big screen TV. In this regards, I am have always hoped for a calamity to force things to happen, like a depression because that it the only way we can get people to go back to the needs first, wants second attitude. As Phil pointed out with his ‘college preps you for real life’ post, the truth is so far from that it is not funny – we need classes in “How I survived the great depression†as a mandatory class in high school. But the American people are fools.

OK solutions….

Yes there is a couple solutions.

First thing is increase interest rates to prop up the dollar. It seems that the economist are all saying we need to increase interest rates but because of the boo hoo crying from the people who over extended themselves with their mortgages to buy a house that they don’t need and they can’t afford, the interest rates are being lowered. It is too bad that some decided not to read the fine print and now blame everyone else for their failure – sell the house, move into an apartment and take the lost. Houses should be long term investments (10 to 20 years) not short term investment vehicle and those who disagree with me too bad, let them lose their investment.

Interest rates will not cause the stock market to crash, as many have feared – the stock market is due for another adjustment soon anyway with all the indicators being inflated. The falling of the dow 1000 points is not the end of the world and looking at the percentage of a drop compared to say the 1930’s we have nothing to worry about long term.

If they raise the interest rates, the dollar will become an investment vehicle again and gain strength. The trade off is that the new housing market will fall flat on its face but that’s alright to many – being one who sees a problem with building houses that just sit while being devalued.

The other solution is to revamp the tax system, yes the Fair Tax is the only way to go right now for a number of reasons, one being the latest out of Washington – “Congress' Stall on Tax Bill Threatens Timely Refunds for Millions of Filers†at

http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/071201/tax_hit.html

Sorry you people who depend on the refund to get things done, you’re the one who should be fighting tooth and nail for the Fair Tax, no withholding means no refund MEANS that your money works for you the instant you earn it – not the government. It is so simple, it is so idiot proof that no one who has a bit of intelligence should defend the present system – but many do because they can’t understand basic economics.

The other that the Fair Tax is a solution is because it allows investments to be made in this country without any punishing taxes. As I know many out there don’t understand that things like depreciation and future tax liabilities actually have a lot to do with how businesses make decisions, how they buy equipment and how they run their labor resources, but with the tax burden removed in the decision making process, there should be more employment, more purchasing of new equipment and more overall money flowing.

Take Ford for instance (true example), they still have some equipment that was made when old man ford was walking the plant floor – they don’t have a replacement built because they can’t justify the purchase due to the depreciation for a machine that is used for an hour a week. Now when you look at a lot of American manufactures, they still have a lot of stuff running because of this issue.

Also think about this, I did a quick comparison to what life would be with the Fair Tax for 2006 to what I had to pay out in taxes and I came out ahead under the fair tax by some $2000. This takes in account all the stuff I purchased for food and truck stuff and money I made from the investments I had. The tax comes to $6000 without the prebate. With the prebate system in the Fair Tax (this brings every house hold up to the poverty level of taxes) so far without a detailed comparison I could be ahead so much that I could be able to do what I need to do with my home and land.

I hope to have exact figures soon.

Learn about it – http://www.fairtax.org
 

OntarioVanMan

Retired Expediter
Owner/Operator
I think the mortagage crisis will be short lived but costly for some...Time will straighten it all out...Anyone who thought they were getting a bargain were in never never land...
Yes the stockmarket is over valued and will adjust...winners and losers as always.

As you said increase the interest rate and federally limit gas and diesel exports tied to domestic use to stabize the national transportation system....
 

Tennesseahawk

Veteran Expediter
China is in the same boat as us, as we depend on each other for survival. China's currency is based off the US dollar. If China decides to change that, the US economy will crash. And with it, the Chinese economy; since we'll stop buying from them.

First off, let's find the blame:
1) Favored nation trade status for China. This has sent most of our manufacturing jobs overseas, and turned the US into a predominately service oriented society.
2) High corporate taxes. We are the second most expensive country to run a business in. That, coupled with #1 is why our manufacturing sector is shattered.
3) Congress. The mentality of "sell tomorrow so we can get elected today" is pretty much self-explanitory. We've been sold out.
4) Our president. See #3.
5) Environmentalism. See #3.
6) Illegal immigrants. See #3.
7) Corporate greed and collusion. The oil companies are artificially raising the prices without regard of what it's doing to the country. Manufacturing companies are also at fault for selling out to profit, ala Wallyworld. See also #3 and 4.
8) Education. Without a clue as to how to budget themselves, America got into trouble with its credit situation. No discipline, and no desire to learn from the past. Obviously, babyboomers aren't passing on what they were taught. I guess they're too busy trying to be their child's friend. See #3, 4, and 7.

Solutions:
1) Lower the corporate tax. Invite our own businesses to remain here.
2) Eject ALL illegal immigrants. Impose stiff penalties on businesses that hire them. Give insentives to businesses that turn illegals in.
3) Get rid of the IRS and several government departments, including Education, the EPA, etc.
4) Put the US back on the gold standard. With something solid backing our currency, we might be able to pull out of this mess. Prices would drop dramatically.
5) Make the Federal Reserve go back under government control.
6) Let the market BE the market. If the US economy is weak, let it fall. Artificially stabilizing it by lowering interest rates will just make tomorrow that much worse. Let those who invested unwisely take the hit they deserve. America will bounce back... just like it did before.
7) Curb government spending!!! Make it a law that pork cannot be added to anything other than a specific pork bill. Military budgets cannot have farm subsidies on it. Education bills cannot have welfare subsidies on it. And so on.
8) Realize that a two-party system fails us. Both parties are killing the US, just in different ways. We have the mentality of voting for one candidate just to keep another candidate out of office. Why should we only have a choice of stepping in mud or stepping in sh1t??? WAKE UP!!!
9) Start with yourself. Get yourself out of debt. Go on a budget. Buy American! I know I'm contradicting what I said before. But this Wal-mart mentality is going to be the end of us! Reward US manufacturers who produce good products at a fair price. Don't immediately go for cheap stuff made elsewhere. You get what you pay for. BTW... Honda and Toyota are more American than the big three! 70% of our Honda was made in the US. The Japanese are smart enough, not only to make a superior vehicle, but to do it at a fair price IN OUR COUNTRY! It can be done!


-A bore is a person who opens his mouth and puts his feats in it. - Henry Ford
 

OntarioVanMan

Retired Expediter
Owner/Operator
GO Hawk!!

Can you imagine if even only 50 million Americans went out tomorrow and bought ONE pair of say jeans. MADE in the U.S.A.
 

greg334

Veteran Expediter
1) Lower the corporate tax. Invite our own businesses to remain here.

Realistically lowering them won’t help, eliminating them is the only way to go. I recommend anyone trying to figure out how business actually should work, look into history of the late 19th century and the absence of taxes how it really mattered. By the way, who actually pays these taxes? Do you think that the companies pay them, no we do.

2) Eject ALL illegal immigrants. Impose stiff penalties on businesses that hire them. Give insentives to businesses that turn illegals in.

Sorry, deportation is not the solution, enforcing the laws and building a big d*mn ditch along the Mexican/US border to start with and then build one on the northern border to keep them Canadians out. Besides closing the border, start using the RICO statue to take business that conspires to use an invasion workforce.

3) Get rid of the IRS and several government departments, including Education, the EPA, etc.

Support the Fair Tax, that does away with the IRS. Get rid of the department of education and outlaw the NEA. Redo the charter of the EPA and have two laws passed that puts the environment issues for oil drilling and refining (oh and nuke power) off limits from all federal courts – it is constitutional so let’s use it.

4) Put the US back on the gold standard. With something solid backing our currency, we might be able to pull out of this mess. Prices would drop dramatically.

NO don’t put the US back on the gold standard; it will cause too many problems. The current problem is directly related to the feds being involved with the money system. As one great economist said, using gold as a standard only makes gold worth the money it is printed on and nothing else.

5) Make the Federal Reserve go back under government control.

Yep it needs serious restructuring and more limits on political control.

6) Let the market BE the market. If the US economy is weak, let it fall. Artificially stabilizing it by lowering interest rates will just make tomorrow that much worse. Let those who invested unwisely take the hit they deserve. America will bounce back... just like it did before.

The lowering of interest rates is not stabilizing the markets, it is harming them in a lot of ways. We have for the most part used interest rates to regulate growth much like we do with taxes for the last 70 years. Let the interest rates go up, let the housing market adjust itself and let people who get over their head with this stupidity of buying for an investment fall. Houses should be homes and people should not move ten times in ten years.

7) Curb government spending!!! Make it a law that pork cannot be added to anything other than a specific pork bill. Military budgets cannot have farm subsidies on it. Education bills cannot have welfare subsidies on it. And so on.

Regardless how you cut it, a republican congress has lost their way and forced itself to be a democratic congress in disguise. The democrats, who promised to eliminate ear marks, who have promised to put a system together that shows the American people what ear marks come from what senators/congressmen have lied to all of us and this applies to the next point, we need a serious change.

8) Realize that a two-party system fails us. Both parties are killing the US, just in different ways. We have the mentality of voting for one candidate just to keep another candidate out of office. Why should we only have a choice of stepping in mud or stepping in sh1t??? WAKE UP!!!

See above point.


9) Start with yourself. Get yourself out of debt. Go on a budget. Buy American! I know I'm contradicting what I said before. But this Wal-mart mentality is going to be the end of us! Reward US manufacturers who produce good products at a fair price. Don't immediately go for cheap stuff made elsewhere. You get what you pay for. BTW... Honda and Toyota are more American than the big three! 70% of our Honda was made in the US. The Japanese are smart enough, not only to make a superior vehicle, but to do it at a fair price IN OUR COUNTRY! It can be done!


Sorry the American people are too stupid to wake up. They don’t get that credit card debt, high debt to income ratio and the idea that they need all this stuff is a big problem for everyone. So what if you can’t pay for heat, you got an Xbox. So what if your children go without so you can go to the foot ball game, someone else will get them those shoes they need to go to school. I know after going to some places in Africa, we don’t know what poverty is about, we complain about not having children covered where their parents make 200% above the poverty level (for a family of 5 that is $45K) with SCHIP program but we don’t think that most of our poor have cell phones, a car and plenty of food.
 

Packmule

Expert Expediter
WOW!!!
Excellent post Hawkman and Greg, EXCELLENT!!!
What gets me is how two guys in the trucking industry can see the problems of the American economy, and identify solutions, then why can't our elected party officials. Maybe you guys are in the wrong field. You would surely have my vote on restructuring the US Economy.

Danny
 

Tennesseahawk

Veteran Expediter
Our representatives do know. The problem is, they are power-:censoredsign:s to the lobbyist-pimps.

-A bore is a person who opens his mouth and puts his feats in it. - Henry Ford
 

Packmule

Expert Expediter
Come on Hawkman... You can't make me believe that!! We the people voted for these fine upstanding folks to represent our best interest!

Danny
 

greg334

Veteran Expediter
Danny,
I think there are no principles with most of these people who run and win for an office.

I talked to my father yesterday about this very subject; my sister lives at a "T" intersection on the left corner. There are people who whip around the corner at 35 MPH where the speed is 25, been a few serious accidents - one where they had to cut the car open to get the guy out. My brother-in-law's father is on the city council and told my father when my father complained, he can not get the city manager to put a stop sign on the corner or tell the cops to sit on the corner to see what happens but instead said that the city needs to put a traffic counter on the corner before they can determine what kind of sign is needed.

See to me he sold out his principles because he should be fighting for a stop sign, not give an excuse why it can't be done. He can put forth a resolution to get that stop sign there, God only knows how many stop signs they have laying around and how many are sitting on a post at the end of a dead end street. The really sad thing is that his grandkids play on the sidewalk right there and may get hurt.

My point is that when someone gets into a position, they get an ego - like the super truck owners I have met that little problems are not important. They don't understand that it is the person who voted for them put them there and they owe it to that voter and all the constituents the best they can do for them.

By the way, you ever notice that many people who get elected on the city council want to raise taxes? What ever happened to lowering taxes?
 
Top