Take construction jobs out of the equation altogether, they are incorrectly counted and have been the crux of the need to throw money into the economy.
The more recent indicators that have been used are even way off, the job improvement of the poster child of the economy "Elkhart Indiana". With the claim fame where Obama had opened his "must do something" program, they boasted a 16% unemployment rate (that is 8% less than Detroit) and now it is something like 14% (or 12 depending on which cooked numbers you want to use).
With over 25% unemployment in Michigan cities, we don't see real improvements anywhere outside of heavely subsidized auto companies.