Emotion vs. Intellect on guns

AMonger

Veteran Expediter
So I visit my family for the holidays, and in the evening some family goes home and my sister and I watch tv. We watch Panic 911, a new series that uses 911 audio and dramatizes it. You periodically see a clock running on the screen showing how long the caller has been on the line, how far away the police are, etc. The calls are chilling, listening as a terrified woman tells a dispatcher the intruder is coming up the stairs right now, she can see his face, and she screams, "GET OUT! GET AWAY FROM ME! NO! DON'T TOUCH ME!" One's heart rate really jumps as one listens.
Now, my sister is no dummy. She's got an MBA, an excellent job with a company everyone knows of, and it's hard to put one over on her. She watches Shark Tank and spots all the mistakes people are making and anticipates the objections the sharks are going to raise, and what the contestants would have/could have/should have done, etc. But on the subject of guns, she's pure emotion. Not just recently; she always has been. And she can raise an issue about guns, purely emotional, and I can respond with facts, numbers, studies, reason, history, etc., and it doesn't make a dent.
When we were watching Panic 911, there was one of those home invasion calls in which a pregnant woman calls 911, saying her dogs are staring downstairs and freaking out, and they're usually very calm dogs. The operator sends some units, but they're 10 minutes away. Meanwhile, the intruder is on his way up the steps and confronts her in the kitchen. He attacks her, ripping the phone out of her hand and strangling her with the cord, and starts to rape her. Eventually, the cops get there, force the door and storm in. The rapist is 6'2" and 320 lbs., and it takes 5 cops to take him down and get him cuffed.
Back up to the point where the rapist confronts her in the kitchen and strangles her with the phone cord. I said, "Too bad she didn't have a gun." That always sets my sister off.
"Yeah, then she could have been arrested or sued!" She had all sorts of objections. Usually it includes "The rapist will just take it from her and use it on her," but not this time.
I rebutted, but she have me a talk-to-the-hand and said, "I don't want to hear it!"
The last thing I said was that a gun makes her his equal, which should make it clear, but she just won't examine the subject any way other than emotionally, and now tens of millions of Americans think like her. I'd hate to think we've reached a tipping point on this, too.
 

LDB

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
Sounds like your sister is a brilliant (on almost everything) idiot (on guns). Good luck. Maybe eventually your intelligence and common sense on the subject will have some effect. Alternatively, one of her friends may eventually be the strangled rape victim and being only one step removed from her may make the change. I'm sure you've used the one about the woman strangled by her own pantyhose vs. the woman unhurt and holding a gun. It's sad people can be so unseeing.
 

AMonger

Veteran Expediter
, but she just won't examine the subject any way other than emotionally, and now tens of millions of Americans [strike]think[/strike] feel like her. I'd hate to think we've reached a tipping point on this, too.
Fixed it for myself.
 

skyraider

Veteran Expediter
US Navy
The people have spoken. The government cannot protect us. House of old silver haired men and women are to old to respond. The Senate is busy watching the u know what videos, and Nancy and Reed are looking for their cheese spread at a Washington fundraiser.

You see now why a free society works. We should think our forefathers for that Constitution for the right to bear arms. Without it, we would really be in deep waste.lol.

Note: Send a postcard to your Senator or Congressman/woman when you get a chance. Everyone will read it along its path IMHO. Think about it.
 

AMonger

Veteran Expediter
And so it continues...
While being subjected to the latest episode of the horrid show Criminal Minds, my sister and I watched as a victim was approached and forced to lay down before being brutally killed. I gave her the "It's too bad she didn't have a gun."
She replied with her usual, "Then he could have taken her gun and used it on her!"
I pointed out, "He already had a gun. He didn't need hers."
Somehow, we got to the point where she said, "She could have run."
"Faster than a bullet? She could have outrun a bullet?"
"She could have zig-zagged!"
Remember, this is from an otherwise intelligent woman, but I don't see how.
I can't stand it.
 

LDB

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
Poking the bear would be extra entertaining when your sister is the bear. And that means nothing more nor less than doing what you do, making sensible statements for her to reply to. One of my friends who is very intelligent with lots of common sense has a sister who is very intelligent and very ignorant. She's a very fun bear to poke also.
 

hossman2011

Veteran Expediter
Owner/Operator
I have an aunt that I have been poking for ting she weeks now... the one posting she made on Facebook was a woman holding a sign that said " If one preschooler hits another one with a rock, do we make sure all the other preschoolers have rocks? " Emotions have always gotten in the way of logic no matter what the subject.. I would bet that your sister has relationship issues too because of emotional issues... I know men like this too..... we are becoming a country of whimps
 
Top